Quick Answer: Which Vinyl Record Player Should You Buy?
If you want a vinyl record player that works right out of the box—with USB recording, DJ capabilities, and no extra gear required—the Audio-Technica AT-LP120XUSB is the smarter buy. If sound quality is your top priority and you're willing to invest in a separate phono preamp, the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO delivers audiophile-grade performance that's hard to beat under $700.
Vinyl Record Player vs Turntable: What's the Real Difference?
You'll see both terms used interchangeably, but here's the simple breakdown: "vinyl record player" is the everyday term most people use, while "turntable" is the more technical name preferred by audiophiles and DJs. In this comparison, we're looking at two turntables designed for serious listening—not the all-in-one suitcase players you'll find at department stores. Both the LP120XUSB and Debut Carbon EVO are built to last and sound great for years.
Sound Quality: AT-LP120XUSB vs Debut Carbon EVO
The Debut Carbon EVO has the edge here. Its carbon fiber tonearm reduces vibration and resonance, and the included Sumiko Rainier cartridge delivers a warmer, more detailed sound than the AT-VM95E on the LP120XUSB.
That said, the LP120XUSB punches well above its $349 price. Most listeners—especially those without high-end speakers—won't notice a dramatic difference in everyday use. The Audio-Technica also lets you upgrade the cartridge later, which narrows the gap considerably.
For critical listening in a quiet room with quality speakers, the Pro-Ject wins. For casual vinyl sessions, the Audio-Technica holds its own.
Setup & Ease of Use for Beginners
The AT-LP120XUSB is the easier vinyl record player to set up. It has a built-in phono preamp, so you can connect it directly to powered speakers or any AUX input. Unbox it, balance the tonearm, and you're spinning records in under 15 minutes.
The Debut Carbon EVO requires a few extra steps. You'll need an external phono preamp or a receiver with a phono input. Setup isn't difficult, but it adds one more piece of gear and one more cable to manage.
If you're new to vinyl and want the simplest path to music, the Audio-Technica is more beginner-friendly.
Do You Need a Phono Preamp for These Turntables?
The LP120XUSB has a built-in preamp with a bypass switch. You can skip the external preamp entirely or disable it later if you upgrade your system.
The Debut Carbon EVO has no built-in preamp. You'll need to budget an extra $50–$150 for a decent phono stage, or use a receiver that has a dedicated phono input.
For beginners, the built-in preamp on the Audio-Technica removes a barrier. For enthusiasts building a hi-fi system, the Pro-Ject's lack of a preamp is actually a feature—it lets you choose exactly the sound signature you want.
Who Each Vinyl Record Player Is Best For
Buy the AT-LP120XUSB if you:
- • Want a plug-and-play vinyl record player with no extra gear
- • Plan to digitize records via USB
- • Are interested in DJing or scratching
- • Prefer features and flexibility over pure sound
Buy the Debut Carbon EVO if you:
- • Prioritize sound quality above all else
- • Already own or plan to buy a phono preamp
- • Want a turntable you won't outgrow
- • Listen to vinyl as your primary music format
Verdict: Final Recommendation
For most first-time buyers, the AT-LP120XUSB is the better choice. It costs $250 less, includes a preamp, and offers features like USB output that the Pro-Ject lacks. You'll get great sound without needing extra equipment.
If you're an intermediate buyer ready to invest in long-term quality—and you have or plan to buy a phono preamp—the Debut Carbon EVO is worth the premium. It's a turntable you can keep for a decade without feeling the urge to upgrade.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the AT-LP120XUSB good for beginners?
Yes. It's one of the most recommended vinyl record players for beginners because of its built-in preamp, easy setup, and room to grow. You can start simple and upgrade the cartridge later.
Can I use the Debut Carbon EVO without a preamp?
No. The Debut Carbon EVO requires an external phono preamp or a receiver with a phono input. Budget $50–$150 extra if you don't already have one.
Which turntable sounds better, LP120 or Debut Carbon EVO?
The Debut Carbon EVO sounds better out of the box, thanks to its carbon fiber tonearm and Sumiko cartridge. However, the difference is subtle for casual listeners, and the LP120XUSB can be upgraded to close the gap.